Skip to Main Content
SUBMIT A TIP RECEIVE DAILY NEWS
Menu AdvisorHub
  • News
      • Latest News
          • Brendan Biruk, Leslie Crilley and Dan Rattigan (left to right) of Washington Crossing Financial Group.LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book
          • Ralph Hamers, CEO of UBS Group AGUBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers
          • DealsHightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA
          • Business DealCI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion
        • Close
      • Advisor Moves
          • Brendan Biruk, Leslie Crilley and Dan Rattigan (left to right) of Washington Crossing Financial Group.LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book
          • Boca Raton, FloridaRockefeller Lures Two Florida Teams with $9.8 Mln Revenue
          • Morgan Stanley, UBS Advisor movesMorgan Stanley Rehires $3.3-Mln UBS Team in North Carolina
          • Lars Olson of Sanctuary Wealth Partners in Marion, OHSanctuary Hires $435-Mln Merrill Team, Snowden Lures Another from Retirement
        • Close
      • Enforcement
          • Advisor MoneyWells Fargo Recoups $2.5 Million from New Jersey Duo
          • Businessman in prison, fraudWells Fargo Claws Back $3 Million from Jailed Ex-Broker
          • Finra signFinra Fines, Supends Ex-Ameriprise Broker Who Flipped ‘A’ Shares
          • Barred from the securities industry.SEC Puts Nail in Ex-Morgan Stanley Broker’s Career Coffin
        • Close
      • Markets
        • `Nothing Safer Than Cash’: Tech Rout Puts Silicon Valley on Edge
        • ‘Any News Is Bad News’ as Earnings Fail to Save Equity Bulls
        • ‘50 Cent’ Profited From Volatility Jump, Wells Fargo Says
        • ‘Beaten Down’ ETF Is a Way to Play Inverted Curve, BofA Says
        • Close
      • Opinion
          • Opinion-How-Will-The-Coronavirus-Affect-The-Stock-Market-Opinion: Coronavirus – What Advisors Need to Know
          • opinion-investors-conquered-fees-next-up-is-their-own-behaviorOpinion: Investors Conquered Fees but Not Their Own Behavior
          • Investor-Confidence-In-Stocks-Rightly-Declines-Opinion-772x485Investor Confidence in Stocks Rightly Declines: Opinion
          • Opinion-Schwabs-Zero-Commission-Decision-Challenges-Its-Ria-ClientsOpinion: Schwab’s Zero Commission Decision Challenges Its RIA Clients
        • Close
      • Fintech News
          • System outageMerrill Systems Hiccuped on Thursday as Stocks Slid
          • 7 dollar rolls‘The Rock’ Invests in Finance App Acorns, and New Users Get $7
          • TraderHigh-Frequency Traders Love Business With Robinhood
          • EtheriumJay Z, Charles Schwab-Backed Ethereum App Opens Doors to Public
        • Close
      • From the Publisher
          • 2021 PredictionsFrom the Publisher: Sirianni’s Predictions for 2021
          • Josh Rogers – 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Josh Rogers, Founder and CEO, Arete Wealth
          • Phil Hildebrandt — 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Phil Hildebrandt, Principal, CEO of Segall Bryant & Hamill
          • Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners-772×485An AdvisorHub Interview with Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners
          • John Peluso – 772×485Timely interview with John Peluso and AdvisorHub CEO Tony Sirianni
          • Louis Dworsky Coronacrash Interview-772×485Coronacrash Update: Hayden Royal’s Louis Dworsky & Tony Sirianni
          • Stratos_Jeff pic.jpg-772×485Coronacrash Update: Stratos Wealth Partners’ Jeff Concepcion & Tony Sirianni
          • coronacrash ben harrison – 772×485Coronacrash Update: BNY Mellon | Pershing’s Ben Harrison & Tony Sirianni
        • Close
    • Close
  • Deals & Comp
  • Recruiting Wire
  • Breakaway Center
  • Resources
    • resources-home-menuResources Home
    • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT RESOURCESPractice Management Resources
    • Transition ResourcesTransition Resources
    • Fintech ResourcesFintech Resources
    • menu fintechFintech Product Directory
    • Menu-Institute-772×485Institute
    • Boutique Wealth AdvisorsBoutique
    • EventsEvents
    • Asset Manager Hub
    • Close
  • AdvisorHub TV
  • Podcasts
  • RIA Center
  • Virtual Summit
close X
March 16, 2018

DOL Fiduciary Rule Appears Headed for the Supreme Court

by Mason Braswell and Jed Horowitz
|
News
|
DOL, Fiduciary
|
No Comments
Share This
SUBMIT A TIP
DOL Fiduciary Rule Appears Headed for the Supreme Court
The United States Supreme Court Building in Washington DC (Mike Kline/Moment/Getty Images)

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday overturned the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule in a split decision that is reverberating throughout the securities industry.

The decision, following a series of courtroom victories for fiduciary rule proponents, adds uncertainty about the controversial rule and opens the door to probable litigation at the highest level, the U.S. Supreme Court, according to several lawyers.

Whether it will convince any firms to change policies limiting or prohibiting the use of commission-based retirement accounts remains to be seen. (Editor’s Note: After publication of this story, Merrill Lynch said it is standing by its no-commision individual retirement account policy.)

The two-to-one decision handed down Thursday evening upends a Dallas district court decision last year upholding the DOL’s statute. The district court called the rule an example of “regulatory abuse of power.”

The Texas court focused on the strings attached to the best-interest contract [BIC] exemption, which allows brokers to receive variable compensation (instead of fixed fees) if they sign contracts binding them to act in clients’ best interests. Much of the securities industry view that exemption as an invitation for class-action lawyers to bring expensive litigation.

Even though the Trump administration has delayed the effective dates of important parts of the rule, such as the BIC, the DOL is likely to fight for preservation of the fiduciary standard rather than risk being sued by advocates of the rule, according to some observers.

“The AARP [American Association of Retired Persons] has said over and over again that if the DOL doesn’t defend its regulation that it is going to,” said Erin Sweeney, a pensions and retirement account lawyer with Miller & Chevalier in Washington D.C. “You wouldn’t want another entity bringing forth your lawsuit.”

A spokesman for the Department of Labor did not return a request for comment.

“It’s not the death knell” for the fiduciary rule, agreed Marcia Wagner, a lawyer in Boston who specializes in retirement account law and who believes that the Fifth Circuit vacature applies only in Texas, Louisiana and New Mexico where the court holds sway. “This is a huge regulatory issue and the Supreme Court should really rule on it.”

Other lawyers have opined that the district court ruling rescinds the rule nationally.

“It’s now up to @SCOTUS to resolve,” Jason Roberts, an ERISA lawyer who is CEO of the Pension Resource Institute, wrote on his LinkedIn blog.

The Fifth Circuit decision is the first court loss for the DOL rule, according to Wagner. As recently as Tuesday, judges on a Tenth Circuit appeals panel in Kansas denied a Topeka insurance agency’s attempt to overturn the rule’s prohibiton on sale of fixed-index annuities.

The Fifth Circuit majority ruled in favor of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and industry trade groups, including the independent broker dealers’ Financial Services Institute and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association. The plaintiffs had argued that the Labor Department went beyond its statutory authority under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act in the way it imposed the requirement that brokers act in their clients’ “best interests” when handling retirement accounts.

“DOL has made no secret of its intent to transform the trillion-dollar market for IRA investments, annuities and insurance products, and to regulate in a new way the thousands of people and organizations working in that market,” the majority opinion said. “It is not hard to spot regulatory abuse of power….”

The circuit court took issue with the agency’s Best Interest Contract Exemption, which includes a private right of action for customers who assert that brokers did not act in their best interest. The DOL under Trump has delayed implementation of the BIC section of the rule until January 2019, and the Securities and Exchange Commission has said it is working with the DOL on cobbling out a broad fiduciary rule going beyond retirement accounts.

The part of the rule requiring brokers to abide by standards of prudence and loyalty—which include charging “no more than reasonable compensation” and making accurate representations about investments, conflicts of interest and compensation, took effect in June last year.

Industry groups urged the SEC to quickly follow up on the decision with its version of a fiduciary standard.

“The court has ruled on the side of America’s retirement savers, preserving access to affordable financial advice,” the Chamber and four other plaintiffs in the case said in a prepared statement. “Our organizations have long supported the development of a best interest standard of care and the Securities and Exchange Commission should now take the lead on a clear, consistent, and workable standard that does not limit choice for investors.” [Editor’s Note: SEC Chairman Jay Clayton said at an industry legal conference on Monday, March 19, that the appeals court decision has not changed his view that his agency should take the lead on writing a fiduciary standard rule.]

Several states, including Nevada and Massachusetts, have been preparing their own fiduciary rules and guidelines, and are prosecuting alleged violations of the existing rule.

“I strongly urge the federal government to appeal this ruling, to provide certainty to customers and their advisers,” William Galvin, Massachusetts’ top securities regulator said in a statement on Friday. “In the meantime, my office will continue to pursue our cases against Scottrade, which involves violations of their own internal policies, and my office retains the authority to pursue investigations involving dishonest and unethical practices.”

Like this article? Let AdvisorHub come to you!  Sign up

Share This
No Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Tony Sirianni Podcast Banner

CORONACRASH NEWS

  • Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Jan 19, 2021
  • Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Jan 8, 2021
  • Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Jan 5, 2021
  • J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    Dec 4, 2020

NEWS

  • LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book

    LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book

    Jan 26, 2021
  • UBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers

    UBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers

    Jan 26, 2021
  • Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Jan 26, 2021
  • CI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion

    CI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Finra Bars Ex-Merrill Broker Kenahan After Record NH Settlement

    Finra Bars Ex-Merrill Broker Kenahan After Record NH Settlement

    Jan 25, 2021

FINANCIAL INDUSTRY PODCASTS

AllIndependenceSuccess
The must listen-to podcast for financial advisors by Tony Sirianni. Guests to include:
-Ron Kruszewski
-Shirl Penney
-Penny Pennington
-Eric Clarke
and many more
Michael Kitces and Carl Richards discuss financial advising topics.
Suzanne Siracuse asks the questions nobody else asks, as influencers and interviewer collide in her new and truly unique podcast series The Big Reveal.
The “new advice value stack,” and how firms can use it to help maximize their own value propositions for their clients.
The Brighthouse Financial Insights Panel is a group of leading, independent experts providing powerful insights into the big challenges facing you and your clients.
Equipping independent financial advisors with the tips, insights, and knowledge needed to evolve in every aspect of his or her life
Powering Independence Podcast, insights and ideas for RIAs, presented by Dynasty Financial Partners. A podcast dedicated to presenting fresh ideas and best practices for the wealth management industry.
As an industry expert, Frank LaRosa provides guidance and advice on a host of topics from recruiting and transitions, succession planning, practice management, M&A and more.
Our goal is to unlock the challenges to reveal the opportunities and what it means to provide advice in the 21st century.
Our webcast is dedicated to helping our viewers get real insights by avoiding the cognitive dissonance of today’s media outlets and biased editorial filters.
Go behind the scenes with registered investment advisors and other related independent business model experts
As a nationally recognized recruiter and consultant to financial advisors, Mindy Diamond has unmatched experience in introducing advisors to the independent space.
The must listen-to podcast for investors, venture capitalists and financial advisors, with Tony Sirianni and Paul Dietrich.
An Introduction to Independence: 5 Key Episodes to Jumpstart Your Knowledgebase
Jay is an investment strategist, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ and business consultant to financial advisors.
In this podcast business owners, entrepreneurs and executives reveal their top tips for success.
We interview top financial advisors and visionary voices to bring you the strategies, tips, and tools you need to make a difference in people’s lives.
A financial literacy and commentary show that features a number of investors, financial experts, professional athletes, business owners and more.
Join Sound Financial Group CEO Paul Adams and President Cory Shepherd every week, as they help you Design and Build a Good Life™.
The Kuderna Podcast, focusing on wealth in it's original meaning- a state of well being.
Timeless wisdom, actionable information you can use right now to make smarter investment decisions.
Made for and dedicated to those folks serious about their financial plan.
Latest News 
Advisor Moves 
Enforcement 
Opinion 
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Events
  • Careers

 get our newsletter

Industry focused content and breaking news.

SIGN UP

Contact Us

EMAIL US
1707 Post Oak Blvd.
#484
Houston, TX 77056

© 2021 AdvisorHub
  • |Terms of Use
  • |Privacy Policy
  • |Advertise
  • |Careers
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Back to top