Skip to Main Content
SUBMIT A TIP RECEIVE DAILY NEWS
Menu AdvisorHub
  • News
      • Latest News
          • DealsHightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA
          • Business DealCI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion
          • Finra signFinra Bars Ex-Merrill Broker Kenahan After Record NH Settlement
          • Female JudgeMorgan Stanley Prevails in TRO Standoff with $6-Mln RBC Team
        • Close
      • Advisor Moves
          • Boca Raton, FloridaRockefeller Lures Two Florida Teams with $9.8 Mln Revenue
          • Morgan Stanley, UBS Advisor movesMorgan Stanley Rehires $3.3-Mln UBS Team in North Carolina
          • Lars Olson of Sanctuary Wealth Partners in Marion, OHSanctuary Hires $435-Mln Merrill Team, Snowden Lures Another from Retirement
          • Stifel Investment CompanyStifel Hires 33-Year Brokerage Vet from Jefferies in Dallas
        • Close
      • Enforcement
          • Advisor MoneyWells Fargo Recoups $2.5 Million from New Jersey Duo
          • Businessman in prison, fraudWells Fargo Claws Back $3 Million from Jailed Ex-Broker
          • Finra signFinra Fines, Supends Ex-Ameriprise Broker Who Flipped ‘A’ Shares
          • Barred from the securities industry.SEC Puts Nail in Ex-Morgan Stanley Broker’s Career Coffin
        • Close
      • Markets
        • `Nothing Safer Than Cash’: Tech Rout Puts Silicon Valley on Edge
        • ‘Any News Is Bad News’ as Earnings Fail to Save Equity Bulls
        • ‘50 Cent’ Profited From Volatility Jump, Wells Fargo Says
        • ‘Beaten Down’ ETF Is a Way to Play Inverted Curve, BofA Says
        • Close
      • Opinion
          • Opinion-How-Will-The-Coronavirus-Affect-The-Stock-Market-Opinion: Coronavirus – What Advisors Need to Know
          • opinion-investors-conquered-fees-next-up-is-their-own-behaviorOpinion: Investors Conquered Fees but Not Their Own Behavior
          • Investor-Confidence-In-Stocks-Rightly-Declines-Opinion-772x485Investor Confidence in Stocks Rightly Declines: Opinion
          • Opinion-Schwabs-Zero-Commission-Decision-Challenges-Its-Ria-ClientsOpinion: Schwab’s Zero Commission Decision Challenges Its RIA Clients
        • Close
      • Fintech News
          • System outageMerrill Systems Hiccuped on Thursday as Stocks Slid
          • 7 dollar rolls‘The Rock’ Invests in Finance App Acorns, and New Users Get $7
          • TraderHigh-Frequency Traders Love Business With Robinhood
          • EtheriumJay Z, Charles Schwab-Backed Ethereum App Opens Doors to Public
        • Close
      • From the Publisher
          • 2021 PredictionsFrom the Publisher: Sirianni’s Predictions for 2021
          • Josh Rogers – 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Josh Rogers, Founder and CEO, Arete Wealth
          • Phil Hildebrandt — 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Phil Hildebrandt, Principal, CEO of Segall Bryant & Hamill
          • Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners-772×485An AdvisorHub Interview with Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners
          • John Peluso – 772×485Timely interview with John Peluso and AdvisorHub CEO Tony Sirianni
          • Louis Dworsky Coronacrash Interview-772×485Coronacrash Update: Hayden Royal’s Louis Dworsky & Tony Sirianni
          • Stratos_Jeff pic.jpg-772×485Coronacrash Update: Stratos Wealth Partners’ Jeff Concepcion & Tony Sirianni
          • coronacrash ben harrison – 772×485Coronacrash Update: BNY Mellon | Pershing’s Ben Harrison & Tony Sirianni
        • Close
    • Close
  • Deals & Comp
  • Recruiting Wire
  • Breakaway Center
  • Resources
    • resources-home-menuResources Home
    • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT RESOURCESPractice Management Resources
    • Transition ResourcesTransition Resources
    • Fintech ResourcesFintech Resources
    • menu fintechFintech Product Directory
    • Menu-Institute-772×485Institute
    • Boutique Wealth AdvisorsBoutique
    • EventsEvents
    • Asset Manager Hub
    • Close
  • AdvisorHub TV
  • Podcasts
  • RIA Center
  • Virtual Summit
close X
November 18, 2019

Indiana Judge’s Denial of “Retaliatory” Edward Jones Filing Makes Waves

by Vicky Ge Huang
|
News
|
Edward Jones, FINRA
|
Comments (5)
Share This
SUBMIT A TIP
Indiana-Judges-Denial-Of-Retaliatory-Edward-Jones-Filing-Makes-Waves
Robert Daly/Caiaimage/Getty Images

A federal judge’s wide-ranging rejection of Edward D. Jones & Co.’s arguments for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against a broker who joined an independent broker-dealer could be useful in other client-solicitation cases, lawyers said.

District Court Judge Sarah Evans Barker of the southern district of Indiana last Thursday ruled that simply notifying former clients of a job change without soliciting their business does not violate employment contracts, a common charge broker-dealers make when seeking to handcuff brokers in their initial days of book-rebuilding at new employers.

The heart of the judge’s order turned on a distinction between informing clients of a move and actually soliciting them to follow.

“[F]inancial advisors can most assuredly be prohibited from ‘soliciting’ clients when doing so contravenes their employment agreements, but they should not be foreclosed from issuing good-faith communications to clients notifying them that he or she has a left a firm,” Barker wrote. “Such a restriction infringes on the rights of consumers more than it protects the plaintiff-employers.”

The 28-page ruling does not set precedent in other jurisdictions but is a “major loss” for Jones and “holds a certain degree of credibility and persuasiveness” for citation purposes, said Thomas B. Lewis, a lawyer at Stevens & Lee in Princeton, N.J., who was not involved in the Indiana case.

“Edward Jones is disappointed,” company spokesman Alex Reed said in an e-mail, noting that the firm continues to seek damages and a restraining order against broker John Kerr in a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority arbitration proceeding.

Kerr worked at Jones for all of his 20-year brokerage career before moving in August to independent broker-dealer Thurston Springer Financial. Jones sued him in September.

Without the court-ordered injunction, Finra arbitration cases cannot proceed under expedited schedules that are important to client account retention in the initial days of a broker’s departure.

Judge Barker’s denials turned on some fact-specific issues. Jones relied on affidavits from the manager who replaced Kerr and from the Westfield, Indiana, branch office administrator with whom he “was at odds” as evidence of his solicitations. The judge dismissed the affidavits as “second-hand assertions”  from officials with “second-hand knowledge.”

She also credited Kerr’s argument that the majority of clients who followed him moved because they were more loyal to him than the firm. “[M]any of the allegedly solicited individuals were Mr. Kerr’s friends and family before they ever were Edward Jones’s clients,” she wrote.

Jones also failed to address Kerr’s assertions that as a certified financial planner he had a fiduciary duty to inform clients of material changes regarding their assets, and that he provided account transfer information only at their request, the judge ruled.

But she reserved much of her sting to Jones’s “apparent inconsistency” in seeking a court-ordered remedy when it encourages its recruits to send the same kind of affiliation announcements he used. She also noted that Jones sent Kerr’s clients a “Finra notice” informing them of his departure the day he left, suggesting they call him if they had questions.

“These glaring insufficiencies in Edward Jones’s request for injunctive relief suggest that its intention in bringing this lawsuit was less about vindicating or recovering from or preventing its loss of client relationships…and more to ‘teach him a lesson’ for having left,” the judge wrote.

Lawyers said many firms have similar policies to those criticized by the judge.

“I think the judge believes that Edward Jones was truly attempting to pull a fast one on the court system,” said James Heavey, the lawyer at Barton LLP in New York who represented Kerr.

 

Like this article? Let AdvisorHub come to you!  Sign up

Share This
Comments (5)
  • on Nov 18 2019, Florida FA says:

    Yes!! So good to see a judge rule this way and Mr. Kerr be able to get this partially behind him.

    I couldn’t imagine being held hostage while clients couldn’t move with him to his new BD.

    Nearly every time there is a breakaway advisor and a TRO, I find it so hypocritical. If the tables were turned, the gaining firm would never turn away the new business that the transferring planner brings with him/her.

    > Reply to Florida FA
    • on Nov 18 2019, George Charles says:

      The firms have done it for decades, while turning a blind eye to the lies the brokers who “inherit” the accounts tell. For a business built on one’s word of honor (hundreds of millions of dollars worth of shares trade every day, verbally) there doesn’t seem to be much gentlemanliness displayed when someone leaves a firm. Pity.

      > Reply to George Charles
    • on Nov 19 2019, Matthew says:

      Bravo Mr Kerr. Jones has been a bully so many times before, hope this protects the client better in the future!

      > Reply to Matthew
    • on Nov 20 2019, John C. Lindsey says:

      STANDING OVATION !!!!

      This is long overdue. It’s about time that EDJ be thwarted in its scorched earth abuse of FA’s who leave in a legal fashion. They have been abusing and taking wanton advantage of our legal system in pursuit of punitive bullying FA’s for DECADES. This judge has seen through their caustic motives and bravely set the record straight. Judge Sarah Evans Barker in a Federal Court has more courage to do the right thing than any industry arbitration proceeding to date. Can’t wait to see the class action suits naming EDJ that follow.

      > Reply to John C. Lindsey
  • on Nov 19 2019, SC Financial Advisor says:

    It’s about time. I remember when I left my prior broker-dealer the claws came out with a vengeance in pursuit of my client relationships, However, at the same time the BD I left was announcing two brokers with 100 million in assets who left their prior BD to come to the one I just left.

    I wish the judge would have just called it what it is with these broker-dealers: It’s not about preserving client relationships, it’s about keeping the assets.

    > Reply to SC Financial Advisor

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Tony Sirianni Podcast Banner

CORONACRASH NEWS

  • Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Jan 19, 2021
  • Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Jan 8, 2021
  • Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Jan 5, 2021
  • J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    Dec 4, 2020

NEWS

  • Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Jan 26, 2021
  • CI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion

    CI Financial Buys Chicago RIA and Asset Manager Overseeing $23 Billion

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Finra Bars Ex-Merrill Broker Kenahan After Record NH Settlement

    Finra Bars Ex-Merrill Broker Kenahan After Record NH Settlement

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Morgan Stanley Prevails in TRO Standoff with $6-Mln RBC Team

    Morgan Stanley Prevails in TRO Standoff with $6-Mln RBC Team

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Thanks, Robinhood, but These Traders Now Want Professional Help

    Thanks, Robinhood, but These Traders Now Want Professional Help

    Jan 25, 2021

FINANCIAL INDUSTRY PODCASTS

AllIndependenceSuccess
The must listen-to podcast for financial advisors by Tony Sirianni. Guests to include:
-Ron Kruszewski
-Shirl Penney
-Penny Pennington
-Eric Clarke
and many more
Michael Kitces and Carl Richards discuss financial advising topics.
Suzanne Siracuse asks the questions nobody else asks, as influencers and interviewer collide in her new and truly unique podcast series The Big Reveal.
The “new advice value stack,” and how firms can use it to help maximize their own value propositions for their clients.
The Brighthouse Financial Insights Panel is a group of leading, independent experts providing powerful insights into the big challenges facing you and your clients.
Equipping independent financial advisors with the tips, insights, and knowledge needed to evolve in every aspect of his or her life
Powering Independence Podcast, insights and ideas for RIAs, presented by Dynasty Financial Partners. A podcast dedicated to presenting fresh ideas and best practices for the wealth management industry.
As an industry expert, Frank LaRosa provides guidance and advice on a host of topics from recruiting and transitions, succession planning, practice management, M&A and more.
Our goal is to unlock the challenges to reveal the opportunities and what it means to provide advice in the 21st century.
Our webcast is dedicated to helping our viewers get real insights by avoiding the cognitive dissonance of today’s media outlets and biased editorial filters.
Go behind the scenes with registered investment advisors and other related independent business model experts
As a nationally recognized recruiter and consultant to financial advisors, Mindy Diamond has unmatched experience in introducing advisors to the independent space.
The must listen-to podcast for investors, venture capitalists and financial advisors, with Tony Sirianni and Paul Dietrich.
An Introduction to Independence: 5 Key Episodes to Jumpstart Your Knowledgebase
Jay is an investment strategist, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ and business consultant to financial advisors.
In this podcast business owners, entrepreneurs and executives reveal their top tips for success.
We interview top financial advisors and visionary voices to bring you the strategies, tips, and tools you need to make a difference in people’s lives.
A financial literacy and commentary show that features a number of investors, financial experts, professional athletes, business owners and more.
Join Sound Financial Group CEO Paul Adams and President Cory Shepherd every week, as they help you Design and Build a Good Life™.
The Kuderna Podcast, focusing on wealth in it's original meaning- a state of well being.
Timeless wisdom, actionable information you can use right now to make smarter investment decisions.
Made for and dedicated to those folks serious about their financial plan.
Latest News 
Advisor Moves 
Enforcement 
Opinion 
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Events
  • Careers

 get our newsletter

Industry focused content and breaking news.

SIGN UP

Contact Us

EMAIL US
1707 Post Oak Blvd.
#484
Houston, TX 77056

© 2021 AdvisorHub
  • |Terms of Use
  • |Privacy Policy
  • |Advertise
  • |Careers
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Back to top