Skip to Main Content
SUBMIT A TIP RECEIVE DAILY NEWS
Menu AdvisorHub
  • News
      • Latest News
          • System outageRobinhood, Schwab Among Online Brokers Hit by Service Disruption
          • GOLDMAN SACHS logoGoldman CEO’s Pay Drops $10 Million on Scandal Punishment
          • Brendan Biruk, Leslie Crilley and Dan Rattigan (left to right) of Washington Crossing Financial Group.LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book
          • Ralph Hamers, CEO of UBS Group AGUBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers
        • Close
      • Advisor Moves
          • Brendan Biruk, Leslie Crilley and Dan Rattigan (left to right) of Washington Crossing Financial Group.LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book
          • Boca Raton, FloridaRockefeller Lures Two Florida Teams with $9.8 Mln Revenue
          • Morgan Stanley, UBS Advisor movesMorgan Stanley Rehires $3.3-Mln UBS Team in North Carolina
          • Lars Olson of Sanctuary Wealth Partners in Marion, OHSanctuary Hires $435-Mln Merrill Team, Snowden Lures Another from Retirement
        • Close
      • Enforcement
          • Advisor MoneyWells Fargo Recoups $2.5 Million from New Jersey Duo
          • Businessman in prison, fraudWells Fargo Claws Back $3 Million from Jailed Ex-Broker
          • Finra signFinra Fines, Supends Ex-Ameriprise Broker Who Flipped ‘A’ Shares
          • Barred from the securities industry.SEC Puts Nail in Ex-Morgan Stanley Broker’s Career Coffin
        • Close
      • Markets
        • `Nothing Safer Than Cash’: Tech Rout Puts Silicon Valley on Edge
        • ‘Any News Is Bad News’ as Earnings Fail to Save Equity Bulls
        • ‘50 Cent’ Profited From Volatility Jump, Wells Fargo Says
        • ‘Beaten Down’ ETF Is a Way to Play Inverted Curve, BofA Says
        • Close
      • Opinion
          • Opinion-How-Will-The-Coronavirus-Affect-The-Stock-Market-Opinion: Coronavirus – What Advisors Need to Know
          • opinion-investors-conquered-fees-next-up-is-their-own-behaviorOpinion: Investors Conquered Fees but Not Their Own Behavior
          • Investor-Confidence-In-Stocks-Rightly-Declines-Opinion-772x485Investor Confidence in Stocks Rightly Declines: Opinion
          • Opinion-Schwabs-Zero-Commission-Decision-Challenges-Its-Ria-ClientsOpinion: Schwab’s Zero Commission Decision Challenges Its RIA Clients
        • Close
      • Fintech News
          • System outageMerrill Systems Hiccuped on Thursday as Stocks Slid
          • 7 dollar rolls‘The Rock’ Invests in Finance App Acorns, and New Users Get $7
          • TraderHigh-Frequency Traders Love Business With Robinhood
          • EtheriumJay Z, Charles Schwab-Backed Ethereum App Opens Doors to Public
        • Close
      • From the Publisher
          • 2021 PredictionsFrom the Publisher: Sirianni’s Predictions for 2021
          • Josh Rogers – 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Josh Rogers, Founder and CEO, Arete Wealth
          • Phil Hildebrandt — 772×485Seven Questions with Tony Sirianni: Phil Hildebrandt, Principal, CEO of Segall Bryant & Hamill
          • Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners-772×485An AdvisorHub Interview with Christian Hyldahl, President of Varium Investment Partners
          • John Peluso – 772×485Timely interview with John Peluso and AdvisorHub CEO Tony Sirianni
          • Louis Dworsky Coronacrash Interview-772×485Coronacrash Update: Hayden Royal’s Louis Dworsky & Tony Sirianni
          • Stratos_Jeff pic.jpg-772×485Coronacrash Update: Stratos Wealth Partners’ Jeff Concepcion & Tony Sirianni
          • coronacrash ben harrison – 772×485Coronacrash Update: BNY Mellon | Pershing’s Ben Harrison & Tony Sirianni
        • Close
    • Close
  • Deals & Comp
  • Recruiting Wire
  • Breakaway Center
  • Resources
    • resources-home-menuResources Home
    • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT RESOURCESPractice Management Resources
    • Transition ResourcesTransition Resources
    • Fintech ResourcesFintech Resources
    • menu fintechFintech Product Directory
    • Menu-Institute-772×485Institute
    • Boutique Wealth AdvisorsBoutique
    • EventsEvents
    • Asset Manager Hub
    • Close
  • AdvisorHub TV
  • Podcasts
  • RIA Center
  • Virtual Summit
close X
July 26, 2018

Opinion: Report Card on an Industry in Transition

by Tony Sirianni
|
Opinion
|
Fiduciary, Prexit, Recruiting
|
Comments (5)
Share This
SUBMIT A TIP
Opinion: Report Card on an Industry in Transition
filo/DigitalVision Vectors/Getty Images

Where have all the leaders gone?

It gives me great pains to write this, but at a time when a fragmented retail brokerage industry is in need of a clear, concise message to attract tomorrow’s investor, few leaders in any segment of the industry are stepping up to instill public confidence in their financial advisors.

The lines among wirehouses, regional firms, independent broker-dealers and even fee-only advisory shops have become increasingly blurred. One can argue that there are 20 types of firms from independent broker-dealer to family office. Firms such as Stifel Nicolaus, Raymond James Financial, JPMorgan, and LPL Financial (what I like to call the “New Nationals”) have the size or many of the characteristics of wirehouses, while Edward Jones with its distinctive offering has more advisors than anyone.

Although our industry distinctions are becoming passé, the lack of a coherent response to regulatory change and technology-enabled disruptors is alarming. Firms continue to fight each other as if nothing has changed, and advisors are lost in the shuffle.

If I were asked to grade retail brokerage leadership as a whole for its response to recent issues and its ability to instill confidence among investors and advisors, I’d give them a C-, at best.

To illustrate, I’ve grouped firms into our three general types and reviewed, among other things, two recent epochal events in this industry: the rise and fall of the DOL Fiduciary Rule and exits from the Protocol for Broker Recruiting (Prexit).

 

The Wires C-

The cracks first appeared with Merrill’s response to the now-defunct Department of Labor customer-care standards. In line with its history of setting precedent and direction for the industry and with its parent bank’s apparent fear of customer litigation, Merrill responded to the proposal with a radical stand that essentially banned commission-based retirement accounts. With the fiduciary rule now dead, Merrill leaders are reviewing whether to modify their position. The morale-hurting damage that the policy inflicted on advisors and, arguably, on customers may not be so easy to reverse.

Morgan Stanley and UBS maintained more flexible approaches on retirement accounts. Nevertheless, the ultimate shelving of the rules in favor of the status quo made a mockery of the industry’s ability to adapt, influence, or even understand where our business is headed.

Not every Wire jumped on the DOL bandwagon, but Morgan Stanley and UBS undoubtedly burned some bridges of their own with their matter-of-fact departures from the Protocol for Broker Recruiting last year. It’s hard to argue that wires led the way, or even had consensus on DOL, but there’s no argument that the Prexit phenomenon is completely of their making.

I admit there is some wisdom to trying to end the no-win prisoner exchange of expensive broker hires that went on for years among the big firms. Surely the big firms with stringent non compete contracts are feeling vindicated as Prexit has put a damper on advisor breakaways, and legal fees likely cost less per share than lost assets.  Time will tell whether these firms will reap a long-term benefit, or have created, as in the case of fired branch managers, a resentful underclass of employees that could come back and haunt them.

To my way of thinking, it’s preposterous to believe that any one firm will have everything that every advisor will find right, for every client, for all time. Trapping clients and advisors at one firm in perpetuity limits industry innovation and chills change at the large institutions.

Wires still have enormous advantages in platform and products, of course. If they can embrace those strengths while showing the flexibility to return to the advisor-centric cultures with which they began, they will remain a relevant force.

 

Regionals/New Nationals B-

Regionals and the New Nats, have been, for the most part, outspoken in their support of advisor-centric issues year to date, IBDs less so. Regionals held steady in the wake of the DOL madness, and have not only stayed in Protocol but been critical of the Wires who have left.

One can call their actions self serving, and that may be true, but regionals have for a long time put clients first, advisors second, and company third. They are culturally bound to advocate for their employees simply because they have to. With no large banks or meaningful trading desks to challenge advisor/client primacy, they ignore their advisors at their own peril.

Why a B-? Regionals et al, have done a terrible job of telling their story, and have not grasped at the laurel of leadership. In many cases their payouts are nearly as good as Indies after expenses, their culture strong, their management boosted by Wirehouse vets, their product platforms tight, but their sophistication and ability to scale is viewed as suspect, as is their technology.

This segment of our industry needs to find its voice. The New Nationals have the size and strength to lead, but continually refuse to take their seats at the big table.

 

Independents/RIAs B

Independents—broker-dealers, registered investment advisors and hybrids—have been the big industry disruptors again this year, and remain the fastest-growing channel. Thanks to the aforementioned technological advances and the blandishments of money-management firms eager for distribution, indies now have top-notch product platforms and plenty of good managers, including a growing number with wirehouse training.

They have been outspoken in their condemnation of Prexit, although some of them have used it to their advantage to sue their own departing advisors. They straight up had no clue on the DOL rule, so they stayed the course, which turned out to be prescient.

Independent growth stems not from their stance on issues of the day, but is due in large part to having won the battle of culture. Wires at first refused to engage in a character debate with a bunch of small firms they didn’t recognize as equals. Once wires realized they were in a fight, it was too late. They already fired their managers (keepers of culture) in the most public way, and engaged in a mercenary war of attrition with themselves by waving huge paychecks. To their chagrin Indies, for the most part without big checks, but many times with former Wire managers, still managed to recruit their advisors away.

The war though, rages on. The culture battle is won, until the Wires wake up to their opportunity to change, but Independence itself is ready for some scrutiny. Not every new indie firm has been a success. Poor leadership, poor planning, and most of all poor financing, have hampered growth at many firms. Billion dollar producers that made headlines jumping from wires to aggregators, are now moving out on their own, creating truly independent firms, and leaving aggregator firms in the lurch.

Many of the firms suffer from their own weak leadership and planning, and need to find sustainable financing models. The shoestring budgets they began with cannot see them through to the finish. I expect many will consolidate to ensure survival in an increasingly expensive world of litigation,  regulation, and the need for technology upgrades.

I’m nevertheless giving the indie leaders an B for innovation, for culture, and for advocating their model. In many ways, it is testimony to having won the cultural battle, without having to use big checks. Culture, for now, has trumped cash.

 

Industry overall C-

Where are our leaders?

The Bull market has covered up a lot of bad decisions. Once the market turns, the emperor will have no clothes, and all the assets that left because they were marginalized and ignored by big firms will be padding other firms books.

We need leadership now. American Politics and regulation are a genuine threat, and need consensus to fight/influence. Internal squabbling is stifling growth and innovation at a time when our industry needs to embrace new technologies and fit them into our matrix at the peril of being subsumed or replaced by them.

But there is hope. As firms distinctions meld there is room for one, or all of our New National firms to set the stage, anticipate the trends, and be mindful about what this business is all about: advisors and clients. Then, maybe, we can compete like adults, and lay our weapons aside to face challenges that impact us all with a collective voice–only then will we have a say in the future of our business, rather than merely a role in tearing it apart.

Like this article? Let AdvisorHub come to you!  Sign up

Share This
Comments (5)
  • on Jul 26 2018, old broker says:

    Amen. everyone should read this

    > Reply to old broker
  • on Jul 26 2018, Regular says:

    a 20% equity correction could put some small RIA’s completely out of business.

    > Reply to Regular
    • on Dec 17 2018, John says:

      And it may have put some of the wires out 10 years ago if the government didn’t bail them out.

      > Reply to John
  • on Jul 26 2018, casey knight says:

    Great job, Tony. This year has shown that there is a lot to be learned, but little willingness to do so. I think this article does a good job at explaining some of the reasons why.

    > Reply to casey knight
  • on Jul 26 2018, wire guy says:

    Well put. The issues are right in front of us. We have never had a good voice speaking on our behalf–one that wasnt ultimately beholden to the very firms that are creating the problems–we need to unionize–around advisorhub?

    > Reply to wire guy

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Tony Sirianni Podcast Banner

CORONACRASH NEWS

  • Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Finra Scrutinizes Brokers Who Took PPP Loans for Potential Violations

    Jan 25, 2021
  • Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Merrill Touts Success of Growth Strategy in Pandemic-Afflicted Year

    Jan 19, 2021
  • Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Raymond James Slashes CEO Pay 17% in Turbulent Year

    Jan 8, 2021
  • Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Solomon Sees Vaccine Bringing Goldman Staff Back by End of Year

    Jan 5, 2021
  • J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    J.P. Morgan Bank Broker Cleared of Coronavirus Crash Claim

    Dec 4, 2020

NEWS

  • Robinhood, Schwab Among Online Brokers Hit by Service Disruption

    Robinhood, Schwab Among Online Brokers Hit by Service Disruption

    Jan 27, 2021
  • Goldman CEO’s Pay Drops $10 Million on Scandal Punishment

    Goldman CEO’s Pay Drops $10 Million on Scandal Punishment

    Jan 27, 2021
  • LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book

    LPL Reels in UBS Pennsylvania Team with $245 Million Book

    Jan 26, 2021
  • UBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers

    UBS Wealth Americas Profit Hits Record with Fewer Brokers

    Jan 26, 2021
  • Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Hightower Takes Stake in $830 Million New York RIA

    Jan 26, 2021

FINANCIAL INDUSTRY PODCASTS

AllIndependenceSuccess
The must listen-to podcast for financial advisors by Tony Sirianni. Guests to include:
-Ron Kruszewski
-Shirl Penney
-Penny Pennington
-Eric Clarke
and many more
Michael Kitces and Carl Richards discuss financial advising topics.
Suzanne Siracuse asks the questions nobody else asks, as influencers and interviewer collide in her new and truly unique podcast series The Big Reveal.
The “new advice value stack,” and how firms can use it to help maximize their own value propositions for their clients.
The Brighthouse Financial Insights Panel is a group of leading, independent experts providing powerful insights into the big challenges facing you and your clients.
Equipping independent financial advisors with the tips, insights, and knowledge needed to evolve in every aspect of his or her life
Powering Independence Podcast, insights and ideas for RIAs, presented by Dynasty Financial Partners. A podcast dedicated to presenting fresh ideas and best practices for the wealth management industry.
As an industry expert, Frank LaRosa provides guidance and advice on a host of topics from recruiting and transitions, succession planning, practice management, M&A and more.
Our goal is to unlock the challenges to reveal the opportunities and what it means to provide advice in the 21st century.
Our webcast is dedicated to helping our viewers get real insights by avoiding the cognitive dissonance of today’s media outlets and biased editorial filters.
Go behind the scenes with registered investment advisors and other related independent business model experts
As a nationally recognized recruiter and consultant to financial advisors, Mindy Diamond has unmatched experience in introducing advisors to the independent space.
The must listen-to podcast for investors, venture capitalists and financial advisors, with Tony Sirianni and Paul Dietrich.
An Introduction to Independence: 5 Key Episodes to Jumpstart Your Knowledgebase
Jay is an investment strategist, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ and business consultant to financial advisors.
In this podcast business owners, entrepreneurs and executives reveal their top tips for success.
We interview top financial advisors and visionary voices to bring you the strategies, tips, and tools you need to make a difference in people’s lives.
A financial literacy and commentary show that features a number of investors, financial experts, professional athletes, business owners and more.
Join Sound Financial Group CEO Paul Adams and President Cory Shepherd every week, as they help you Design and Build a Good Life™.
The Kuderna Podcast, focusing on wealth in it's original meaning- a state of well being.
Timeless wisdom, actionable information you can use right now to make smarter investment decisions.
Made for and dedicated to those folks serious about their financial plan.
Latest News 
Advisor Moves 
Enforcement 
Opinion 
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Events
  • Careers

 get our newsletter

Industry focused content and breaking news.

SIGN UP

Contact Us

EMAIL US
1707 Post Oak Blvd.
#484
Houston, TX 77056

© 2021 AdvisorHub
  • |Terms of Use
  • |Privacy Policy
  • |Advertise
  • |Careers
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Back to top